dcm4chee
  1. dcm4chee
  2. DCMEE-1767

Private attributes in NM Images duplicated, and in wrong order

    Details

    • Type: Bug Bug
    • Status: Open
    • Priority: Minor Minor
    • Resolution: Unresolved
    • Affects Version/s: dcm4chee-2.16.2
    • Fix Version/s: None
    • Component/s: None
    • Labels:
      None
    • Environment:
      dcm4chee-2.16.2-mysql running with DefaultSettings on 32-Bit Debian, mysql 5.1.41, Compression: NONE,
        dcm4che-2.0.25 toolkit for testing

      Description

      Image sent to dcm4chee, then sent with dcm4chee-web to dcmrcv.

      dcmrcv is accepting the image,
      other dicom-receivers (MergeToolkit) abort with:
      Tags not in ascending order: (7fe0,0010) found after (7fe3,1016)

      Original Image has following Private attributes: (dcm2txt)

      ...
      528328:(0043,0010) LO #14 [SIEMENS MED NM] Private Creator Data Element
      528350:(0043,1003) UN #1440 [\02\F1\E3\BE5\00\E4\BEi\0F\E4\BE\9C\1E\E4\BEX\EA\
      529798:(0043,1004) UN #1440 [M*\00\BFM2\00\BFM:\00\BFMB\00\BF\1A%\00\BF\E7\07\
      ...
      532584:(7FE0,0010) OW #262144 [0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0
      794736:(7FE3,0010) LO #14 [SIEMENS MED NM] Private Creator Data Element
      794758:(7FE3,1014) UN #8 [\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00] ?
      794774:(7FE3,1015) UN #8 [\00\00H\00\00\001\00] ?
      794790:(7FE3,1016) UN #8 [\02\00\EC\83\02\00\8Fr] ?
      

      Same Image, received and sent from dcm4chee looks like this:

      ...
      528444:(0043,0000) UL #4 [5868] Group Length
      528456:(0043,0010) LO #14 [SIEMENS MED NM] Private Creator Data Element
      528478:(0043,0011) LO #16 [dcm4che/archive] Private Creator Data Element
      528502:(0043,1003) UN #1440 [\02\F1\E3\BE5\00\E4\BEi\0F\E4\BE\9C\1E\E4\BEX\EA\
      529950:(0043,1004) UN #1440 [M*\00\BFM2\00\BFM:\00\BFMB\00\BF\1A%\00\BF\E7\07\
      531398:(0043,1103) UN #1440 [\02\F1\E3\BE5\00\E4\BEi\0F\E4\BE\9C\1E\E4\BEX\EA\
      532846:(0043,1104) UN #1440 [M*\00\BFM2\00\BFM:\00\BFMB\00\BF\1A%\00\BF\E7\07\
      534294:(0043,1114) UN #6 [DUMMY ] ?
      534308:(0043,1115) UN #8 [LISEEXP ] ?
      ...
      535758:(7FE3,0000) UL #4 [70] Group Length
      535770:(7FE3,0010) LO #14 [SIEMENS MED NM] Private Creator Data Element
      535792:(7FE3,1014) UN #8 [\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00] ?
      535808:(7FE3,1015) UN #8 [\00\00H\00\00\001\00] ?
      535824:(7FE3,1016) UN #8 [\02\00\EC\83\02\00\8Fr] ?
      535840:(7FE0,0010) OW #262144 [0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0
      797992:(7FE3,0000) UL #4 [92] Group Length
      798004:(7FE3,0010) LO #14 [SIEMENS MED NM] Private Creator Data Element
      798026:(7FE3,1010) UN #14 [SIEMENS MED NM] ?
      798048:(7FE3,1014) UN #8 [\00\00\00\00\00\00\00\00] ?
      798064:(7FE3,1015) UN #8 [\00\00H\00\00\001\00] ?
      798080:(7FE3,1016) UN #8 [\02\00\EC\83\02\00\8Fr] ?
      
      1. dump.nm_anon_chee.txt
        15 kB
        gerhard h
      2. dump.nm_anon.txt
        14 kB
        gerhard h
      3. nm_anon_chee.dcm
        779 kB
        gerhard h
      4. nm_anon_chee-2.17.txt
        14 kB
        Gunter Zeilinger
      5. nm_anon.dcm
        776 kB
        gerhard h

        Issue Links

          Activity

          Hide
          gerhard h added a comment -

          dump.nm_anon.txt dcm2txt Dump of orig Image
          dump.nm_anon_chee.txt dcm2txt Dump of dcm4chee exported Image

          Show
          gerhard h added a comment - dump.nm_anon.txt dcm2txt Dump of orig Image dump.nm_anon_chee.txt dcm2txt Dump of dcm4chee exported Image
          Hide
          gerhard h added a comment -

          nm_anon.dcm Original image
          nm_anon_chee.dcm dcm4chee exported Image

          Show
          gerhard h added a comment - nm_anon.dcm Original image nm_anon_chee.dcm dcm4chee exported Image
          Hide
          Gunter Zeilinger added a comment - - edited

          I could not reproduce the issue with current dcm4chee trunk, even without using fixed DCMOLD-220 dcm4che.jar. (see attached Dump of dcm4chee exported Image: nm_anon_chee-2.17.txt )

          Show
          Gunter Zeilinger added a comment - - edited I could not reproduce the issue with current dcm4chee trunk, even without using fixed DCMOLD-220 dcm4che.jar. (see attached Dump of dcm4chee exported Image: nm_anon_chee-2.17.txt )
          Hide
          gerhard h added a comment -

          Gunter you are right - with 2.17 the Image is exported correct.
          ( but only if the original image was also received with 2.17. )

          Show
          gerhard h added a comment - Gunter you are right - with 2.17 the Image is exported correct. ( but only if the original image was also received with 2.17. )
          Hide
          Sabine Kolics added a comment -

          can not be reproduced wether with 2.16 nor with 2.17

          Show
          Sabine Kolics added a comment - can not be reproduced wether with 2.16 nor with 2.17

            People

            • Assignee:
              Gunter Zeilinger
              Reporter:
              gerhard h
            • Votes:
              0 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              1 Start watching this issue

              Dates

              • Created:
                Updated:

                Development